VS

[fangirl1981]

Now that Supernatural is going into hiatus till January I thought I'd do a comparison of the season 2 episodes vs the season 1 episodes.
I'm bolding the episodes I like better:

#1.1 Pilot vs #2.1 "In My Time of Dying"
#1.2 Wendigo vs #2.2 Everybody Loves a Clown
#1.3 Dead in the Water vs #2.3 Bloodlust
#1.4 Phantom Traveler vs #2.4 Children Shouldn't Play with Dead Things
#1.5 Bloody Mary vs #2.5 Simon Said
#1.6 Skin vs #2.6 No Exit
#1.7 Hookman vs #2.7 The Usual Suspects
#1.8 Bugs vs #2.8 Cross Road Blues
#1.9 Home vs #2.9 Croatoan

Looks like season 2 is winning five to four.